|
My colleagues and advisers never seem to agree about how and when the Gerber convention can be used. Most agree that if clubs have been bid, the Blackwood convention is appropriate. Others maintain that it is still correct to bid four clubs.
Iceberg, Kelowna, British Columbia
Here’s when to use Gerber in suit auctions: never. I suggest to you that a call of four clubs is always a cuebid, rather than Gerber, unless it is a jump after a call of no-trump. I know my readers will never buy this, and that it is a losing battle to suggest it. So let’s at least agree that when it isn’t a jump, a call of four clubs is never Gerber. And it is never, ever, Gerber when clubs are trump.
Recently as dummy I saw my partner playing a three heart contract in which the opponents revoked in mid-hand. If the renege had not been caught, declarer would have been down one. He now receives two tricks from opponents. The question is, do these tricks give him game or just the contract and an overtrick?
Cereal Killer, Pinehurst, N.C.
The contract is three hearts – regardless of any revoke(s). The penalty can’t exceed the number of tricks taken by the offenders on or after the offence. If the revoker (personally, not his partner) won the revoke trick, the penalty is two tricks. If the revoker didn’t win that trick, the penalty is one trick, UNLESS the revoker subsequently won a trick with a card he could have played legally on the revoke trick. Also, a director can restore equity if the penalty does not suffice.
We have a pair at our club who play a weak no-trump. Do you consider that it is best to play a double of Stayman or of their transfer call by an unpassed hand as relating to the suit they have just bid, or to show points?
Al Dente, Cincinnati, Ohio
|
By a passed hand, all doubles are lead directing. A double of Stayman or an artificial transfer call by an unpassed hand might sensibly be played as strong, unlinked to clubs. But a double of a natural response should just be take-out.
Holding: ♠ Q-2, ♥ A-Q-7-5-2, ♦ A-J-9-3, ♣ 3-2 I opened one heart and after a two club response I bid two diamonds. Now my partner bid two spades and the next hand doubled. What should I have bid without the double – and what with it?
Wheaties, Tacoma, Wash.
Without the double, you would have to bid two no-trump – the doubleton queen is almost as good as a stopper, and if partner has an honor, no-trump is probably better played your way up. After the double you can pass, suggesting this pattern, or a hand with three spades but no wish to bid no-trump.
Please advise your bid with this hand. Holding ♠ Q-7-2, ♥ 2, ♦ J, ♣ A-K-Q-10-8-4-3-2 I gambled to open two clubs, and rebid three clubs. My partner used Blackwood and drove us to six no-trump, which made on a finesse. Was I out of line to do so much?
Fortunate Son, Myrtle Beach, S.C.
Your idea was not a bad one, but the problem is that when partner has scattered values he will assume you own more quick tricks than you have. Here is a good rule; with a long strong suit open two clubs if all one-level responses from partner would leave you without a bid. Even so, open at the one-level unless you have at least one and a half quick tricks outside your long solid suit. Change a red card to an ace here, and you are closer to the mark.
|
The profits for Frank Stewart’s latest book go directly to local causes. “Play Bridge with Me” is available from the writer $23.95 postpaid to the US (signed on request) from PO Box 962 Fayette AL 35555.
Frank declared this deal from the book in a Sectional Swiss Teams. Against six spades West led the diamond two, East playing the jack, and Stewart ruffed and drew trump, finding East with a singleton. That player discarded two diamonds, as dummy also let go of a diamond.
With 11 top tricks, there are many chances for one more. One option is to take the top hearts and ruff a heart, hoping for a 3-3 break. If hearts broke 4-2, declarer could try a club finesse of the jack. If it won, he could ruff another heart, setting up the fifth heart for 13 tricks. If the club finesse lost, declarer would still get home if the clubs broke 3-3 or perhaps (if East failed to return a club) with a squeeze.
But Stewart did better. At the fifth trick he led a heart, and when West followed low, instead of playing an honor from dummy, he ducked in dummy. He ruffed the diamond return, then took both top hearts and ruffed a heart. Now he crossed to dummy with the club king to take the fifth heart for his 12th trick.
As you can see, the unfriendly lie in hearts and clubs make this the only winning line; and had hearts broken 5-1, declarer would still have been able to fall back on the club finesse of course.