Aces on Bridge — Daily Columns

The Aces on Bridge: Tuesday, October 4th, 2011

Dealer: West

Vul: Both

North

8 2

Q J 8 5 3 2

5 3

J 10 9

West

10 3

A K 9

A K J 10 4

K 6 2

East

6 5

7 6 4

9 7 6

8 7 5 4 3

South

A K Q J 9 7 4

10

Q 8 2

A Q

 

South West North East
  1 Pass Pass
Dbl. Pass 1 Pass
3 NT All Pass    
       

Opening Lead: Diamond King

“They studied at the self-same schools,

And shaped their thoughts by common rules.”


— Thomas Hardy

Working out declarer’s likely holding was the key to Kyle Larsen’s brilliant defense on this hand, originally reported by Alan Truscott. His victim was Jill Meyers, whose team nevertheless went on to win the match. The deal was short-listed for defense of the year about a decade ago. The deal is particularly satisfying because it goes against all the rules of defense by setting up tricks for declarer, not your own side.

 

Against three no-trump Larsen led a top diamond, and when dummy appeared, he paused to take stock. Declarer’s double, followed by her jump to game, showed a very strong hand, one likely to have a long running suit, which, judging from West’s hand, could only be spades.

 

South was marked with queen-third of diamonds for her final bid, and if she held seven spades, that left only three cards in the rounded suits.

 

So Larsen cashed his heart ace and king, and South was squeezed. Had she discarded a minor-suit card, West would have continued with that suit.

 

In fact, South chose to discard a spade. As a spade switch would have been fatal, giving declarer access to dummy’s now established hearts, Larsen cashed the diamond king and continued with the jack. This gave declarer her eighth trick, but she was unable to engineer the ninth.

 

Even if declarer had started with just six spades, West would still have needed to cash the top hearts now to prevent being thrown in with them later.


BID WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

A K Q J 9 7 4
10
Q 8 2
A Q

 

South West North East
    1
Dbl. Pass 1 1
?      
       
ANSWER: You are never going to stop short of game here, so it would be simple just to bid four spades. However, just in case your partner has good diamonds (in which case slam might make) cue-bid two clubs first. If your partner jumps in diamonds, you might consider going beyond four spades. If not, you can bid four spades at your next turn.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Monday, October 3rd, 2011

Dealer: South

Vul: East-West

North

10 9 5

Q 6 2

K Q 8 6

K 4 3

West

J 7 6 2

J 4

J 10 4 2

A 6 2

East

K 8 4 3

A 10 8 7

J 10 9 8 5

South

A Q

K 9 5 3

A 9 7 5 3

Q 7

 

South West North East
1 NT Pass 3 NT All Pass
       
       
       

Opening Lead: Spade Two

“Hateful to me as the gates of Hades is that man who hides one thing in his heart and speaks another.”


— Homer

My friend Billy Clegg, a multiple winner of the Ace of Clubs award, was the CEO of an elite office supply house in San Antonio, The Clegg Company, and he and his wife, Terri, were among the best players in town.

 

Clegg believed strongly in opening one no-trump when at all possible to conceal suits and have the opening lead come up to the strong hand. Sixty years ago it was frowned upon to take liberties with one-no-trump openings — there were those who believed it was verboten with 5-4-2-2 shape or with a suit completely unstopped.

 

Years later, the expert community is now echoing the advantages of opening one no-trump whenever possible, but Billy was there before them.

 

In this deal from a team game, Clegg reached no-trump from the South seat, whereas in the other room that South opened his hand one diamond. Three no-trump was played by North, down immediately on a club lead.

 

On a spade lead Clegg won in hand and carefully played diamonds in the recommended way by cashing the diamond ace first, since he knew he could not guard against 4-0 diamonds with East having the length. After finessing the diamond eight, he saw East pitch a spade and a heart, so he led a heart to his hand, setting up the hearts before the clubs.

 

He won the spade return, repeated the diamond finesse, and led a club toward his queen. The defenders had two spades and two aces, but that was all.


LEAD WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

9 6 5 3
K 6
9 7 6
7 5 4 3

 

South West North East
1 Pass 1
Pass 2 Pass 4 NT
Pass 5 Pass 6
All Pass      
ANSWER: I would not lead a diamond (partner had a chance to double a diamond bid and did not do so). The choice is a spade, hoping to set up a winner before declarer develops one of the side-suits for discards, or a club, hoping to give partner a ruff when in with the heart king. Both plans are perfectly reasonable; I tend to favor the second approach.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Sunday, October 2nd, 2011

Dear Mr. Wolff:

How should I value 10s, and five-card suits in deciding whether to open the bidding? Are there 14-counts I can upgrade to a one-no-trump opening, or 11-counts I should open at the one-level?

—  Stretch, Little Rock, Ark.

ANSWER: When in doubt, trust your instincts to evaluate balanced hands. I upgrade 14-counts or downgrade 18-counts to open one no-trump when sensible. Equally, with a decent five-card suit and a little shape in an 11-count, and particularly if I have an easy rebid, I will open the bidding. It is important to try to get partner off to the right lead. Whoever said “Thrice blest is he who gets his blow in first” knew what he was talking about.

Dear Mr. Wolff:

I held SPADES J-9-6, HEARTS J-9-2, DIAMONDS 3-2, CLUBS A-Q-10-4-3, and passed. My LHO bid one spade, my partner overcalled three hearts (intermediate), and my RHO bid three spades. Did I have enough to bid now?

—  Head-First, Sacramento, Calif.

ANSWER: I would bid, but I would not raise to four hearts. As a passed hand I can bid four clubs, meaning it as an unequivocal call in support of hearts. This gets my partner off to the best lead against four spades if the opponents decide to bid on over our four-heart contract.

Dear Mr. Wolff:

Are there advantages to leading fourth highest as opposed to third and lowest against suit contracts? Is it worth changing from the former method to the latter?

—  Looking for an Edge, Midland, Mich.

  ANSWER: The advantages of one method over the other are pretty small. You tend to find out more about suit length when you lead low from three or five cards and third highest from four. You sometimes find out more about honors if you play fourth highest and second from four small. So long as you don’t lead MUD from three cards, any method of leading is fine by me.

Dear Mr. Wolff:

In second seat, holding SPADES Q-J-9-4, HEARTS A-Q-7-3, DIAMONDS K-10, CLUBS 9-6-4, I elected to double a one-club opening bid. I heard one heart on my right and two diamonds from my partner. Was I wrong to try to improve the contract by bidding two no-trump? I did not achieve my target!

—  Fallen Oak, Great Falls, Mont.

ANSWER: A double is normally shape-suitable for the unbid major(s) with opening values. If off-shape, you should have real extras. When balanced with a stopper in their suit, pass with a minimum, unless you have the right shape. But with 15-17, bid one no-trump; with 18-20, double then bid no-trump. Here doubling is fine, but you must pass the response. You gambled and lost — don’t make it worse!

Dear Mr. Wolff:

What is the best way to learn about advanced card play such as squeezes? What are the best books on the subject?

—  Advanced Placement, Boise, Idaho

ANSWER: Without wanting to sound too revolutionary, I strongly advise you to focus on drawing trumps, taking finesses and cashing winners. I promise you that most declarer-play errors at the top level fall into those areas and not squeezes. The basic squeeze is well covered in a book called “Squeezes Made Simple” by Marc Smith and David Bird — but don’t say I didn’t warn you!

 


If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, e-mail him at [email protected]. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011.

The Aces on Bridge: Saturday, October 1st, 2011

Dealer: South

Vul: East-West

North

A K J 3

K Q

5 3

9 7 5 3 2

West

9 8 5 4 2

3

Q J 10 4 2

J 6

East

Q 10 7 6

8 7 5 4 2

A 8

K 4

South

A J 10 9 6

K 9 7 6

A Q 10 8

 

South West North East
1 Pass 1 Pass
2 Pass 2 Pass
3 Pass 4 Pass
4 Pass 4 Pass
6 All Pass    

Opening Lead: Diamond Queen

“You, for example, clever to a fault.”


— Robert Browning

We all have the chance to be brilliant when we have plenty of time at our disposal. However, the problem in real life is not only to find the deception, but also to produce the play in perfect tempo. If we find the right false-card, but break tempo to produce it, declarer can normally see through our little game. With that advance warning, can you see how it might have been possible to deflect declarer from the winning path in today’s deal?

 

North’s decision to cue-bid facing short spades might have been ill-advised and encouraged his partner to look for the club slam. As it was, when West led the predictable diamond queen, declarer found himself in a horrid spot. He won the diamond king at trick two, crossed to the heart king, played a club to the queen, then crossed his fingers and laid down the club ace. When the king and jack appeared, he had his slam in the bag.

 

So who could have done better? West had a shot to deflect declarer from the winning line, if he had dropped the club jack under the queen. Declarer would surely have played West for a singleton club now. He would try to cross to dummy in hearts to repeat the trump finesse — disaster! West would ruff in and lead a third diamond, promoting the club king in East’s hand for down two. So much for a friendly trump break!


BID WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

Q 10 7 6
8 7 5 4 2
A 8
K 4

 

South West North East
  1 1
?      
       
       
ANSWER: The choice is a simple one: do you make a negative double, suggesting 4-4 in the majors, or do you bid one heart and temporarily bury the spade suit, hoping that the auction works out to allow you or your partner to bid spades later on if necessary? I’m strongly of the opinion that you really only have four hearts not five, so make the negative double and don’t worry about missing the 5-3 heart fit.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Friday, September 30th, 2011

Dealer: South

Vul: East-West

North

10 7 3

7 4

J 8 7 5 3

8 7 5

West

5

J 10 9 3 2

6 4 2

K 10 4 2

East

J 6 2

K Q 8 6 5

10 9

J 9 6

South

A K Q 9 8 4

A

A K Q

A Q 3

 

South West North East
2 Pass 2 Pass
2 Pass 3 * Pass
3 NT Pass 4 Pass
6 All Pass    
*Artificial, second negative

Opening Lead: Heart Jack

“Although I enter not,

Yet round about the spot

Ofttimes I hover.”


— William Makepeace Thackeray

In six spades you appear to need a 2-2 trump break or the bare spade jack, in which case 13 tricks rate to be available. If they do not break, you might think you need a miracle in clubs, or a defensive error. In fact, though, once trumps break 3-1, the contract is safe against any lie of the cards.

 

On the lead of the heart jack to the ace, declarer cashes the spade ace as both defenders follow. It would be easy (but very foolish) to play a second top trump and cross your fingers. Essentially you would be playing for an overtrick and risking the contract in the process. The key point of the deal lies in the quality of dummy’s spade intermediates.

 

Instead of taking a second top spade, cash the diamond ace, king and queen. As soon as either defender ruffs in, declarer can regain the lead, draw the last trump, then cross to the spade 10 to pitch the two club losers on the remaining diamond winners.

 

Suppose instead that East discards on the third top diamond. Then declarer leads the spade nine to dummy’s 10. The best East can do is to take the trick and play back a club, but declarer wins the ace, goes to dummy with the trump seven, and takes his discards on the diamonds again.

 

The play works in exactly the same way if it is West who has the spade length.


BID WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

5
J 10 9 3 2
6 4 2
K 10 4 2

 

South West North East
  1 1 Dbl.
Pass 2 Dbl. Pass
?      
       
ANSWER: Your partner’s double shows extras and is for takeout. It might look tempting to pass and play for penalties, but such an action puts a lot of pressure on your partner — and if it doesn’t work, he may never reopen with shortness again. Instead of going for the jugular, just remove the double to three clubs and hope that the opponents bid on, unaware of the breakers ahead.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Thursday, September 29th, 2011

Dealer: South

Vul: East-West

North

K 5 4

A 6 4

Q 5 2

10 9 6 2

West

9 8 3

K Q J 9

K 9 8 7 6

7

East

7 2

10 5 2

A J 10 3

K 8 5 4

South

A Q J 10 6

8 7 3

4

A Q J 3

 

South West North East
1 Pass 2 Pass
3 Pass 4 All Pass
       
       

Opening Lead: Heart King

“Human life is everywhere a state in which much is to be endured, and little to be enjoyed.”


— Samuel Johnson

At the Dyspeptics Club there are many players who would buy into Gore Vidal’s comment that it was not enough that they should succeed. Additionally, others must fail. Of course, it is almost impossible for both sides to be happy at the end of any deal, but today East and West’s pleasure was certainly increased by North’s visible discomfort when play was over.

 

The action in four spades proceeded speedily. The heart king was led to dummy’s ace, and declarer drew trumps ending in dummy. Then he passed the club 10, and when it held the trick, he irritated his partner even further by a premature comment that finally a finesse had worked for him. South repeated the club finesse, leading to his jack, but the 4-1 club break meant he still had a club loser since he could no longer reach dummy to repeat the finesse. There were three inevitable red-suit losers, so the game had to go down.

 

South airily remarked that there was nothing he could do; North riposted that indeed there was nothing South could have done — but a bridge player might have stood a better chance of making the game. Do you see what he meant?

 

Best play after winning the heart ace at trick one is to lead the club two to the queen. Then comes the spade ace, spade queen, and a spade to dummy’s king. After all the trumps are drawn, then running the club 10 produces a painless 10 tricks.


BID WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

K 5 4
A 6 4
Q 5 2
10 9 6 2

 

South West North East
    1 Pass
1 NT Pass 2 Pass
?      
       
ANSWER: You must raise to three clubs for two reasons. The first is that although it is unlikely, your side might have a good play for game. The second is that you know the opponents have a good fit in one major or the other, and raising to three clubs makes it harder for them to get into the act.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Wednesday, September 28th, 2011

Dealer: South

Vul: East-West

North

A 8 4

K 7 5

A 7 4 2

K 9 2

West

K Q J 6 3

A

Q 9 8 6 5

Q 6

East

10 7 5

J 10 6 3

10 3

8 7 4 3

South

9 2

Q 9 8 4 2

K J

A J 10 5

 

South West North East
1 2 * 4 All Pass
       
       
       
*Spades and a minor, 5-5 pattern

Opening Lead: Spade King

“To fall into a habit is to begin to cease to be.”


— Miguel de Unamuno

Today’s deal, reported by Tim Bourke of Australia, features Bill Jacobs, declarer in four hearts. If you were South, knowing that West held at least 10 cards in spades and diamonds, wouldn’t you be inclined to play East for the club queen? So would I, but at the table Jacobs found a better approach.

 

Against four hearts West led the spade king, which Jacobs ducked. He won the spade continuation and ruffed dummy’s last spade to hand, eliminating the suit. Now he led a heart toward the king, won by the ace.

 

West was endplayed (since a spade would let declarer pitch a club from dummy and ruff clubs in the North hand). West elected to get off play with a diamond. South won his jack, cashed the diamond king, then played three rounds of hearts to East.

 

At this point, declarer was able to claim the rest. Since West had shown five spades and five diamonds, it was a sure thing that East had nothing left but clubs in the three-card ending and was thus endplayed, forced to open up the clubs for declarer.

 

It is always entertaining to endplay both of your opponents, even though superior guesswork would also have sufficed. More to the point, it should also aggravate them both — no bad thing to accomplish on a single deal!


BID WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

9 2
Q 9 8 4 2
K J
A J 10 5

 

South West North East
    1 Pass
1 3 Pass Pass
?      
       
ANSWER: Rightly or wrongly, I would not sell out here. I would bid four clubs, knowing that our side must have at least an eight-card fit somewhere and hoping that game might make in either clubs or hearts, remote as that might seem after North’s second-round pass.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Tuesday, September 27th, 2011

Dealer: East

Vul: Both

North

10 5 4 2

A J 8 4

2

J 7 6 4

West

A K Q 8 3

Q 3

J 8 5

Q 10 8

East

J 9 6

9

A 10 9 7 4 3

K 5 3

South

7

K 10 7 6 5 2

K Q 6

A 9 2

 

South West North East
      Pass
1 1 3 3
4 All Pass    
       

Opening Lead: Spade King

“Immortal patriots! Rise once more:

Defend your rights, defend your shore.”


— Joseph Hopkinson

In today’s deal you had to decide whether to take the push to four spades or sit back and try to beat your opponents’ game. With no extra spade length, the key may be whether partner has short hearts (and the opponents are bidding on shape) or whether he has two or three hearts, when you may be able to set their game and the sacrifice would prove expensive. On balance it seems right to pass.

 

Against South’s four hearts you lead the spade king, partner plays the six (suggesting an odd number) and declarer the seven. How do you hope to take four defensive tricks?

 

You need to place partner with the diamond ace and a top club, or both top clubs. Accordingly, it looks important to switch to a club now.

 

If partner has both minor-suit aces, or both top clubs, any small club will probably suffice. However, if partner has the club king without any intermediates and declarer has the club A-9, a switch to the club eight will not be good enough. Declarer will play low from dummy and hold his club losers to one.

 

To cover every possible situation, you must switch to the club 10. If declarer plays low from dummy, so will your partner, and your 10 will force declarer’s ace. However, if he covers your 10 with the jack, your Q-8 will be poised over his 9-2 when partner gets in with the diamond ace and leads clubs again.


BID WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

10 5 4 2
A J 8 4
2
J 7 6 4

 

South West North East
    2 Pass
2 Pass 2 Pass
?      
       
ANSWER: Obviously you have a great hand for spades. The best way to agree spades and get your assets across is to start with a jump to four diamonds. This is a splinter-jump, setting spades and showing values with a singleton diamond. Even if partner signs off in four spades, you are probably worth one further effort — a five-heart cue-bid looks right.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Monday, September 26th, 2011

Dealer: South

Vul: North-South

North

9 7 5 3

8 5

8 6 4 2

K 9 6

West

A K Q J 4

10 7 4 2

J

8 7 3

East

8 6

Q J 9 6 3

10 9 7 3

5 2

South

10 2

A K

A K Q 5

A Q J 10 4

 

South West North East
2 2 Pass Pass
3 Pass 4 Pass
5 All Pass    
       

Opening Lead: Spade King

“That life is worth living is the most necessary of assumptions, and were it not assumed, the most impossible of conclusions.”


— George Santayana

Knowing which cards to keep as a defender may sometimes depend on what declarer doesn’t do.

 

Today’s hand comes from “Planning in Defence” — part of the excellent Bridge Technique Series (Master Point Press), written by David Bird and Marc Smith. Put yourself in the East seat and walk through the play until you come to the critical moment.

 

West leads three rounds of spades against five clubs. Declarer ruffs the third round, then continues with four rounds of clubs. You are in the East seat and have discarded one heart on the third spade and another on the third club. This means that you are down to heart Q-J-9, and diamond 10-9-7-3 and must make yet another discard. So what do you choose?

 

(Incidentally, in the real world, you might be able to rely on some suit-preference clues from your partner. But let’s assume you are playing with a player whom you do not trust.)

 

In these situations it is usually right to retain the same suit length as dummy, or as declarer, if his length in the side-suits is known. Therefore it looks best to retain four diamonds. However, there is a more accurate pointer.

 

Declarer made no attempt to ruff a heart in dummy. Therefore you can conclude that he had no need to do so. Accordingly, he holds no more than a doubleton in the suit. Hence, he has four diamonds, so you must retain that suit.


LEAD WITH THE ACES

South Holds:

Q 9 8
J 6
J 10 4
J 8 6 4 2

 

South West North East
    Pass 1 NT
Pass 3 NT All Pass  
       
       
ANSWER: At teams you would probably look to a fourth-highest club or an attacking lead like a small spade as your best shot to beat the hand. At pairs I prefer the diamond jack as least likely to cost a trick. At matchpoints your main objective is to do one trick better than others with your cards. Occasionally, an attacking lead from a bad suit in a bad hand will set the game; more often, it will cost a trick to no good purpose.

 


For details of Bobby Wolff’s autobiography, The Lone Wolff, contact [email protected]. If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, please leave a comment at this blog. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011. If you are interested in reprinting The Aces on Bridge column, contact [email protected].

The Aces on Bridge: Sunday, September 25th, 2011

Dear Mr. Wolff:

I read in my ACBL bulletin that the recent spring nationals were a triumph for the younger players. Did you follow the results? Were there any surprises in the names who made it to the top?

—  Junior Jim, Charlottesville, Va.

ANSWER: The most successful player was Joel Wooldridge, who won two of the pair games and finished second in a third (then later won the U.S. trials to represent us in the Bermuda Bowl). Joel had played for the United States in Junior events for a full decade by the time he reached 26, so it was no surprise to see him at the top. And keep an eye on NAOP pairs winner Shane Blanchard, who is not only very promising but extremely inexperienced by comparison.

Dear Mr. Wolff:

What are your minimum requirements for an opening bid? What would you open with: SPADES Q-J-9-4, HEARTS A-Q-7, DIAMONDS K-3-2, CLUBS 10-9-2? And would the form of scoring or the vulnerability matter?

—  Open with Care, Palm Springs, Calif.

ANSWER: I’m much more inclined to open a real suit than a three-carder when balanced with a 12-count, though I do open most 12-counts. I’d be more inclined to open that hand when nonvulnerable. The form of scoring does not have a huge impact on my decision.

Dear Mr. Wolff:

Often when I make a takeout double, I want to bid again because I have perfect shape though a minimum hand. Say I double one heart and it is raised to two hearts (or even to three hearts). If my partner passes, how much do I need to act again?

—  Caught in the Headlights, Muncie, Ind.

  ANSWER: I would always pass with a 4-4-4-1 pattern in the 11-14 range. I might have missed a penalty double when my partner has a trump stack, but equally there are many bad things that can happen if he does not! With a trump void I might reopen more aggressively, and with 15-plus and perfect shape I will bid again. However, the real problem comes with 17-19 and a 4-4-3-2 pattern. Bidding again may turn a plus score into a minus, while passing might miss a game.

Dear Mr. Wolff:

Were there any new admissions to the ACBL Hall of Fame this year?

—  Star-Struck, Grenada, Miss.

ANSWER: No players were voted in. A large crop of women turned 60 this year and they may have kept one another out, since the voting procedure allows the voters to select only three names from the roster, no matter how many names are on that list. I was delighted, though, that Eric Kokish was admitted for his service to the game, and Russ Arnold for his long playing career.

Dear Mr. Wolff:

How would you handle SPADES J-9, HEARTS K-J-2, DIAMONDS 10-8-7, CLUBS K-J-9-4-3 when you hear a strong no-trump on your left, three spades from partner and four hearts on your right? Is my hand more about offense than defense? I elected to pass, and found that our side had only one heart trick and that my partner had club length, not diamond length. So a save would have been comparatively cheap.

—  Non-Combatant, Galveston, Texas

ANSWER: You made a sensible call in my opinion. Change your hearts to ace-third and the save looks more attractive — but it could still backfire badly. When the opponents have guessed what to do, as here, sacrificing often gives them a fielder’s choice.

 


If you would like to contact Bobby Wolff, e-mail him at [email protected]. Reproduced with permission of United Feature Syndicate, Inc., Copyright 2011.