|
I was recently faced with a problem when I had a flat two-count with just the queen of diamonds, and my partner opened two clubs. My RHO overcalled two spades, a suit in which I had just three small cards. Should I pass, double, or try something else? And if I pass, what should I do over a double from my partner?
Jungle George, Tupelo, Miss.
Many play that responder's double here would be weak, with any hand in the 0-4 range, say. Pass would show some values but nothing to say, while new suits are natural though not necessarily full positive values. If opener doubles, the world is divided into those who play it as takeout, and those who believe it should be penalties — either the suit, or strong balanced with a moderate holding in the key suit. Put my vote in the takeout camp.
I was delighted to read in a recent letter that you plan to write more for the broader audience of us who are social bridge players and bridge students and are open to suggestions. That is very encouraging. So would you please explain how to transfer into a minor over one no-trump.
House of Windsor, Fremont, Calif.
A simple scheme (not necessarily best, but simplest) is to use two spades to show clubs and three clubs to show diamonds, with two no-trump remaining natural. After a transfer into a minor, new suits should be shortage, not length. With a minor and a four-card major, plus the values to go to game, start with Stayman. Then bid the minor, if partner does not come through with a fit for you.
How should I decide whether to play in a 5-3 fit or in no-trump? My partner and I had the Jacoby Transfer sequence: 1 NT – 2 ♦ – 2 ♥ – 2 NT, and I had to decide what to do next. I held ♠ A-J-5, ♥ Q-6-4, ♦ A-J-10-3-2, ♣ K-10. I elected to pass, thinking I had a minimum, and that turned out to be the wrong thing to do!
Linked In, Raleigh, N.C.
|
You may have only a minimum in high cards, but your quick tricks and excellent five-card suit suggest you are closer to jumping to four hearts, than signing off in three. I would always play in a 5-3 fit unless my trumps were uninspiring, and I had a real source of tricks in a side-suit. (In the given hand, switch the heart queen and diamond three, for example.)
I held ♠ A-K-9-8, ♥ A-Q-6-2, ♦ K-Q-9-7-3, ♣ —. I opened one diamond and my partner responded one spade. Now what should I have done? At the table I felt I was too strong to splinter, and my high cards seemed prime. So I reversed to two hearts, planning to support spades next, probably with a jump. Subsequently I read about the difference between a jump to three hearts and a jump to four — but I'm not sure what is standard practice here.
Feeling Jumpy, Elmira. N.Y.
With two hearts natural and forcing, jumps in hearts would both show shortage — perhaps the former a singleton, the latter a void. But where the shortage is clubs, a jump to three clubs would be natural, so a call of four clubs is either a singleton or void. With your actual hand I would be a little worried about just bidding four clubs and giving up over a sign-off in four spades. But on balance that must be right.
When partner opens with one club, which could be short, and an opponent bids one diamond, am I required to bid with no high-card points but with a five-card suit?
Shorty, Danville, Ind.
A possibly short club is rarely, if ever, played as forcing. So with zero points you can always pass. There are quite a few hands in the range of 3-5 high-card points where I would respond to one club to try to improve the contract despite my overall weakness, but where I won't bid if the opponents overcall.
|
Arguably, it is easier to learn from other people's mistakes than from your own. Have a look at what happened here to South; but before you criticize him, consider whether you are entitled to cast the first stone.
At the table South did not compete to three spades, refusing to be pushed just because of his decent spades. But when his partner doubled, announcing the balance of power, he wisely decided not to defend, and found himself in game a moment later.
So far so good. But after the lead of a heart to the ace, East continued with the heart queen which declarer covered and West ruffed. When the club shift came and both minor-suit finesses failed, South was down one. He could feel justifiably aggrieved at the bad luck he had run into in all three of the side-suits.
South was undeniably unlucky. But he had the fate of the contract in his own hands.
All declarer had to do was duck the second heart rather than cover the queen. The spot-card led had made the 7-1 break somewhat more likely than usual, after all. West would not be able to afford to ruff the trick or declarer has a home for dummy’s club loser, so he discards a club. The next heart is ruffed and overruffed. But now South simply draws trump and passes the diamond jack, not caring if it loses since he now has a home for dummy’s club loser on the fourth diamond.